Project 2044: Fordyce, R.E., Marx, F.G. 2018. Gigantism precedes filter feeding in baleen whale evolution. Current Biology. 28:1670-1676.e2.
Specimen: † Llanocetus denticrenatus (USNM:183022)
View: anterolateral

Abstract

Baleen whales (Mysticeti) are the largest animals on Earth, thanks to their ability to filter feed huge volumes of small prey from seawater. Mysticetes appeared during the Late Eocene, but evidence of their early evolution remains both sparse and controversial, with several models competing to explain the origin of baleen-based bulk feeding. Here, we describe a virtually complete skull of Llanocetus denticrenatus, the second-oldest (ca 34 Ma) mysticete known. The new material represents the same individual as the type and only specimen, a fragmentary mandible. Phylogenetic analysis groups Llanocetus with the oldest mysticete, Mystacodon selenensis, into the basal family Llanocetidae. Llanocetus is gigantic (body length ca 8 m) compared to other early mysticetes. The broad rostrum has sharp, widely-spaced teeth with marked dental abrasion and attrition suggesting biting and occlusal shearing. As in extant mysticetes, the palate bears many sulci, commonly interpreted as osteological correlates of baleen. Unexpectedly, these sulci converge on the upper alveoli, suggesting a peri-dental blood supply to well-developed gums, rather than to inter-alveolar racks of baleen. We interpret Llanocetus as a raptorial or suction feeder, revealing that whales evolved gigantism well before the emergence of filter feeding. Rather than driving the origin of mysticetes, baleen and filtering likely only arose following an initial phase of suction-assisted raptorial feeding. This scenario strikingly differs from that proposed for odontocetes, whose defining adaptation ? echolocation ? was present even in their earliest representatives.


Read the article »

Article DOI: 10.1016/j.cub.2018.04.027

Project DOI: 10.7934/P2044, http://dx.doi.org/10.7934/P2044
This project containsMatrices
  • 5617 Media
  • 1 Matrix
  • 3 Documents
  • 106 Taxa
  • 294 Specimens
  • 275 Characters
Total size of project's media files: 2.28G

Download Project SDD File
Total scored cells: 29213
Total media associated with cells: 17480
Total labels associated with cell media: 18229
Characters
Total characters: 275
Total characters with associated media: 0
Total characters with media with labels: 0
Total character states: 645
Total character states with associated media: 0
Total character states with media with labels:0
Total unordered/ordered characters:237/38
Currently Viewing:
MorphoBank Project 2044

    Authors' Institutions

    • Museum Victoria, Melbourne

    • National Museum of Natural History, Smithsonian Institution

    • Monash University

    • University of Otago

    • Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences

    • Smithsonian Institution



    Members

    member name taxa specimens media media
    notes
    chars character
    notes  media
    labels
    cell scorings
    (scored, NPA, "-")
    cell
    notes  medialabels
    rules
    Felix Marx
    Project Administrator
    1062945617532752190029213
    (16140, 11841, 1232)
    3714849182290
    Seth Kaufman
    000000000
    (0, 0, 0)
    0000


    Taxonomic Overview for Matrix 'M3690' (106 Taxa)

    taxon unscored
    cells
    scored
    cells
    no cell
    support
    NPA
    cells
    "-" cellscell images labels on
    cell images
    member
    access
    [1] † Zygorhiza kochii
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    025001873133322
    [2] † Albertocetus meffordorum
    Last Modified in 12/04/17
    0188075122752802
    [3] † Archaeodelphis patrius
    Last Modified in 06/16/15
    0102016491191262
    [4] † Olympicetus avitus
    Last Modified in 11/07/17
    0137012991521592
    [5] † Waipatia maerewhenua
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    0217045132472612
    [6] Physeter macrocephalus
    Last Modified in 12/15/17
    0227211392632762
    [7] † Aetiocetus cotylalveus
    Last Modified in 06/16/15
    0164010921972122
    [8] † Aetiocetus polydentatus
    Last Modified in 06/16/15
    0175229731922062
    [9] † Aetiocetus weltoni
    Last Modified in 06/16/15
    018808432202302
    [10] † Aglaocetus moreni
    Last Modified in 06/16/15
    01400123121561582
    [11] † Aglaocetus patulus
    Last Modified in 06/16/15
    0187077132242352
    [12] † Archaebalaenoptera castriarquati
    Last Modified in 06/16/15
    0980160171191222
    [13] † Aulocetus latus
    Last Modified in 12/15/17
    099017061131182
    [14] † Balaena montalionis
    Last Modified in 06/16/15
    07101861886902
    [15] Balaena mysticetus
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    025302233093172
    [16] † Balaena ricei
    Last Modified in 06/16/15
    0960161181161222
    [17] † Balaenella brachyrhynus
    Last Modified in 06/16/15
    01340121201711752
    [18] Balaenoptera acutorostrata
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    025900172843012
    [19] † Balaenoptera bertae
    Last Modified in 06/16/15
    0700198794992
    [20] Balaenoptera bonaerensis
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    025405162993122
    [21] Balaenoptera borealis
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    025801172792982
    [22] Balaenoptera musculus
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    025603172953102
    [23] Balaenoptera omurai
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    0252246716002
    [24] Balaenoptera physalus
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    025901172913102
    [25] † Balaenoptera portisi
    Last Modified in 06/16/15
    0180083122272382
    [26] † Balaenoptera ryani
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    081791905112
    [27] † Balaenoptera siberi
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    01580103161841902
    [28] † Balaenula astensis
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    01460110191881882
    [29] † Balaenula sp.
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    01250132181491542
    [30] † Brandtocetus chongulek
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    0122014861511652
    [31] Caperea marginata
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    025203263593762
    [32] † Cephalotropis coronatus
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    013813612512112
    [33] † Cetotherium megalophysum
    Last Modified in 12/15/17
    011711414217002
    [34] † Cetotherium rathkii
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    01390118181651702
    [35] † Cetotherium riabinini
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    0185073172152202
    [36] † Chonecetus sookensis
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    0790194293992
    [37] † Coronodon havensteini
    Last Modified in 08/25/17
    020107052692772
    [38] † Diorocetus chichibuensis
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    0176086132102132
    [39] † Diorocetus hiatus
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    0213049132632792
    [40] † Diorocetus shobarensis
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    01270136131601642
    [41] † Diunatans luctoretemergo
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    0123014941491592
    [42] † Eomysticetus whitmorei
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    0181079152142212
    [43] † Eschrichtioides gastaldii
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    01440113181701742
    [44] Eschrichtius robustus
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    026300173203342
    [45] † Eubalaena ianitrix
    Last Modified in 11/07/17
    0690200693952
    [46] † Eubalaena shinshuensis
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    05502021877772
    [47] Eubalaena spp.
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    025800234034182
    [48] † Fragilicetus velponi
    Last Modified in 11/02/16
    08711854991072
    [49] † Fucaia buelli
    Last Modified in 08/03/15
    0148012431751832
    [50] † Fucaia goedertorum
    Last Modified in 12/16/15
    019207942352402
    [51] † Gricetoides aurorae
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    08201921961052
    [52] † Herentalia nigra
    Last Modified in 02/08/16
    0678201772772
    [53] † Herpetocetus bramblei
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    01450113171811992
    [54] † Herpetocetus morrowi
    Last Modified in 02/17/16
    0217041193293472
    [55] † Herpetocetus sp.
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    0640204778812
    [56] † Herpetocetus transatlanticus
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    0116015271531712
    [57] † Horopeta umarere
    Last Modified in 03/29/16
    01180145121391402
    [58] † Incakujira anillodefuego
    Last Modified in 10/02/16
    0203358162452492
    [59] † Isanacetus laticephalus
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    0197064152442512
    [60] † Janjucetus hunderi
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    018108861912012
    [61] † Joumocetus shimizui
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    01160144151361412
    [62] † Kurdalagonus mchedlidzei
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    01290130161571672
    [63] † Llanocetus denticrenatus
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    017909152252322
    [64] † Mammalodon colliveri
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    017509372062192
    [65] † Mammalodon hakataramea
    Last Modified in 09/11/15
    0370239041392
    [66] † Matapanui waihao
    Last Modified in 08/25/17
    01210139151471532
    [67] † Mauicetus parki
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    0183147801337402
    [68] † Megaptera hubachi
    Last Modified in 12/15/17
    0183075172202282
    [69] † Megaptera miocaena
    Last Modified in 12/15/17
    01500107181922092
    [70] Megaptera novaeangliae
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    026101153293462
    [71] † Metopocetus durinasus
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    081018861031142
    [72] † Metopocetus hunteri
    Last Modified in 03/29/16
    0107016271321442
    [73] † Metopocetus vandelli
    Last Modified in 12/15/17
    0101016961221292
    [74] † Micromysticetus rothauseni
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    090018321051142
    [75] † Miocaperea pulchra
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    01370118211651732
    [76] † Morawanocetus yabukii
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    014064130592942
    [77] † Morenocetus parvus
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    0113015751441502
    [78] † Mystacodon selenensis
    Last Modified in 08/25/17
    0127914351351392
    [79] † Nannocetus eremus
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    089018421131232
    [80] † NMNS PV19540
    Last Modified in 12/29/16
    01681669018002
    [81] † NMNZ MM001630
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    01951836218002
    [82] † OCPC 1178
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    091891822002
    [83] † OU 22224
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    01071041662002
    [84] † OU 22705
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    015114911014002
    [85] † OU GS10897
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    056552173002
    [86] † Parabalaenoptera baulinensis
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    0162098151901932
    [87] † Parietobalaena campiniana
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    01530108141911932
    [88] † Parietobalaena palmeri
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    0217050132802892
    [89] † Parietobalaena sp.
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    01540106151791882
    [90] † Parietobalaena yamaokai
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    0174091132122182
    [91] † Pelocetus calvertensis
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    0220041142522552
    [92] † Peripolocetus vexillifer
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    060582141112
    [93] † Pinocetus polonicus
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    01150148121231252
    [94] † Piscobalaena nana
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    0242015193003092
    [95] † Plesiobalaenoptera quarantellii
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    01370121171481572
    [96] † Thinocetus arthritus
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    01430120121701762
    [97] † Tiphyocetus temblorensis
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    0710204081842
    [98] † Titanocetus sammarinensis
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    01390125111561602
    [99] † Tiucetus rosae
    Last Modified in 09/15/17
    0139013511731772
    [100] † Tohoraata raekohao
    Last Modified in 03/31/16
    0113016021261332
    [101] † Tokarahia kauaeroa
    Last Modified in 03/31/16
    01490113131721762
    [102] † Uranocetus gramensis
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    0173086161911962
    [103] † Waharoa ruwhenua
    Last Modified in 11/07/16
    0198062173093132
    [104] † Whakakai waipata
    Last Modified in 01/26/17
    0800194195992
    [105] † Yamatocetus canaliculatus
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    0191070142182202
    [106] † ZMT 67
    Last Modified in 06/17/15
    014013912213002


    Project views

    type number of views Individual items viewed (where applicable)
    Total project views101147
    Project overview2057
    Matrix views1302Matrix landing page (882 views); Mysticetes mark II (420 views);
    Documents list534
    Media views34746Media search (2259 views); M462871 (1 view); M344531 (2 views); M344454 (3 views); M344461 (8 views); M344446 (1 view); M344584 (1 view); M410639 (4 views); M340860 (177 views); M340865 (188 views); M340809 (229 views); M340871 (164 views); M340858 (160 views); M340804 (215 views); M340881 (186 views); M340856 (170 views); M340837 (178 views); M340819 (210 views); M340799 (202 views); M340788 (220 views); M340816 (224 views); M340872 (172 views); M340829 (191 views); M340854 (165 views); M340863 (168 views); M340883 (157 views); M340813 (218 views); M340847 (160 views); M340840 (157 views); M340796 (249 views); M340857 (204 views); M340817 (210 views); M340807 (223 views); M340874 (180 views); M340827 (211 views); M340823 (194 views); M340879 (169 views); M340794 (217 views); M340802 (212 views); M340844 (171 views); M340864 (181 views); M340834 (176 views); M340835 (199 views); M340831 (185 views); M340885 (174 views); M340789 (239 views); M340848 (172 views); M340797 (208 views); M340859 (166 views); M340815 (221 views); M340824 (193 views); M340849 (178 views); M340793 (205 views); M340843 (171 views); M340790 (223 views); M340880 (189 views); M340877 (176 views); M340798 (204 views); M340869 (170 views); M340801 (223 views); M340875 (204 views); M340845 (162 views); M340846 (160 views); M340884 (163 views); M340828 (177 views); M340867 (178 views); M340795 (225 views); M340826 (204 views); M340806 (221 views); M340820 (227 views); M340866 (160 views); M340808 (221 views); M340803 (216 views); M340861 (166 views); M340873 (211 views); M340811 (219 views); M340830 (194 views); M340870 (158 views); M340814 (200 views); M340855 (164 views); M340833 (178 views); M340853 (176 views); M340839 (179 views); M340836 (175 views); M340841 (163 views); M340825 (200 views); M340882 (164 views); M340800 (216 views); M340842 (172 views); M340791 (212 views); M340812 (209 views); M340810 (210 views); M340851 (171 views); M340887 (180 views); M340850 (156 views); M340838 (165 views); M340805 (229 views); M340792 (213 views); M340832 (179 views); M340876 (166 views); M340821 (199 views); M340862 (183 views); M340818 (218 views); M340822 (203 views); M340868 (176 views); M340852 (167 views); M340886 (164 views); M340878 (176 views); M340995 (99 views); M340891 (100 views); M340899 (105 views); M340905 (106 views); M341012 (106 views); M340914 (105 views); M340952 (112 views); M340994 (94 views); M340941 (104 views); M340931 (108 views); M340949 (112 views); M340977 (103 views); M340962 (104 views); M341011 (100 views); M340956 (111 views); M341005 (99 views); M340895 (107 views); M340922 (105 views); M340968 (108 views); M340900 (108 views); M340957 (104 views); M340910 (102 views); M341000 (97 views); M340897 (107 views); M340970 (109 views); M341008 (104 views); M341006 (105 views); M340964 (111 views); M340972 (111 views); M340976 (110 views); M341010 (102 views); M340925 (106 views); M340937 (104 views); M340981 (108 views); M340955 (109 views); M340980 (105 views); M340892 (108 views); M340986 (110 views); M341003 (105 views); M340945 (110 views); M340921 (104 views); M340926 (104 views); M340969 (106 views); M340893 (105 views); M340982 (106 views); M340903 (109 views); M341004 (103 views); M340904 (106 views); M340946 (108 views); M340940 (108 views); M340888 (106 views); M340901 (110 views); M340930 (108 views); M340938 (105 views); M340911 (103 views); M340933 (105 views); M340908 (103 views); M340984 (108 views); M340939 (105 views); M340990 (103 views); M340950 (110 views); M340983 (110 views); M340965 (110 views); M340961 (105 views); M340967 (110 views); M340951 (102 views); M340944 (112 views); M340960 (106 views); M341009 (103 views); M340959 (115 views); M340971 (109 views); M340929 (108 views); M340909 (100 views); M340932 (97 views); M340928 (102 views); M340973 (110 views); M340915 (103 views); M340996 (101 views); M340889 (103 views); M340890 (108 views); M340997 (105 views); M340913 (107 views); M340963 (107 views); M340906 (99 views); M340923 (102 views); M340992 (107 views); M340912 (98 views); M340953 (104 views); M340917 (103 views); M340894 (100 views); M340896 (109 views); M340898 (99 views); M340902 (105 views); M340907 (106 views); M340916 (107 views); M340918 (105 views); M340919 (105 views); M340920 (109 views); M340924 (99 views); M340927 (102 views); M340934 (107 views); M340935 (103 views); M340936 (106 views); M340942 (111 views); M340943 (105 views); M340947 (102 views); M340948 (109 views); M340954 (104 views); M340958 (111 views); M340966 (108 views); M340974 (93 views); M340975 (102 views); M340978 (109 views); M340979 (105 views); M340985 (108 views); M340987 (109 views); M340988 (104 views); M340989 (107 views); M340991 (106 views); M340993 (106 views); M340998 (103 views); M340999 (99 views); M341001 (100 views); M341002 (101 views); M341007 (105 views); M345767 (1 view); M345769 (2 views); M345797 (2 views); M345798 (1 view); M344464 (5 views); M344542 (3 views); M410640 (2 views); M410638 (1 view); M344458 (8 views); M344459 (27 views); M344572 (4 views); M344573 (7 views); M344455 (3 views); M344575 (7 views); M410839 (1 view); M452467 (1 view); M344583 (1 view); M344536 (1 view); M410635 (3 views); M410622 (1 view); M410637 (1 view); M344460 (1 view); M342136 (1 view); M344605 (1 view); M344606 (2 views); M344540 (1 view); M344457 (2 views); M341140 (1 view); M341141 (1 view); M341142 (1 view); M341143 (1 view); M341147 (1 view); M342748 (1 view); M342749 (1 view); M342750 (1 view); M342751 (1 view); M342762 (1 view); M342761 (1 view); M342752 (1 view); M342753 (1 view); M342823 (1 view); M342839 (1 view); M345352 (1 view); M345353 (1 view); M345361 (1 view); M345365 (1 view); M342962 (1 view); M342966 (1 view); M342727 (2 views); M342724 (1 view); M342788 (1 view); M342787 (1 view); M342792 (1 view); M342891 (1 view); M343372 (1 view); M343380 (1 view); M343389 (1 view); M345610 (1 view); M345638 (1 view); M341529 (1 view); M341531 (1 view); M341530 (1 view); M344852 (1 view); M344854 (1 view); M345479 (1 view); M345488 (1 view); M345485 (1 view); M342414 (1 view); M342380 (1 view); M342728 (1 view); M342893 (1 view); M342556 (4 views); M342666 (1 view); M342674 (3 views); M342676 (4 views); M342682 (2 views); M342693 (2 views); M342706 (4 views); M342699 (1 view); M342989 (4 views); M342664 (2 views); M342665 (1 view); M342669 (1 view); M342671 (1 view); M342683 (1 view); M342686 (1 view); M342687 (1 view); M342690 (1 view); M342695 (1 view); M342697 (1 view); M342698 (2 views); M342704 (1 view); M342689 (1 view); M342701 (2 views); M343554 (1 view); M343552 (1 view); M343210 (1 view); M379508 (1 view); M379497 (2 views); M379494 (2 views); M379495 (2 views); M379496 (2 views); M379501 (1 view); M379500 (1 view); M379499 (1 view); M379503 (2 views); M379510 (2 views); M410674 (3 views); M344848 (6 views); M345779 (1 view); M345570 (1 view); M345780 (1 view); M345781 (3 views); M345317 (3 views); M345319 (1 view); M345325 (1 view); M345396 (1 view); M345397 (1 view); M345399 (1 view); M345532 (1 view); M345802 (2 views); M345876 (1 view); M345758 (1 view); M343096 (2 views); M343097 (1 view); M343098 (1 view); M343099 (1 view); M343104 (1 view); M343105 (1 view); M343111 (1 view); M343209 (1 view); M343211 (1 view); M342550 (1 view); M342553 (2 views); M342570 (1 view); M342559 (1 view); M342561 (1 view); M342565 (1 view); M342568 (1 view); M342571 (1 view); M342581 (1 view); M344010 (1 view); M344011 (1 view); M381629 (1 view); M342171 (1 view); M379498 (1 view); M341346 (1 view); M341343 (1 view); M341929 (1 view); M341927 (1 view); M341939 (1 view); M341942 (1 view); M381607 (1 view); M343524 (1 view); M343651 (1 view); M466463 (1 view); M343531 (2 views); M343488 (1 view); M343492 (1 view); M343486 (1 view); M343662 (1 view); M343528 (1 view); M343530 (1 view); M343534 (1 view); M341065 (1 view); M341060 (1 view); M341018 (1 view);
    Views for media list2298
    Specimen list48011
    Taxon list6513
    Bibliography5686




    Project downloads

    type number of downloads Individual items downloaded (where applicable)
    Total downloads from project259
    Matrix downloads70Mysticetes mark II (70 downloads);
    Document downloads12Palatal sulci and body size optimisation (4 downloads); Institutional abbreviations (1 download); Supplementary Nexus file (7 downloads);
    Project downloads135
    Media downloads42M379508 (1 download); M379497 (2 downloads); M379494 (1 download); M379495 (2 downloads); M379496 (2 downloads); M379501 (1 download); M379500 (1 download); M379499 (1 download); M379503 (2 downloads); M379510 (2 downloads); M410674 (2 downloads); M343097 (1 download); M343098 (1 download); M343099 (1 download); M343104 (1 download); M343105 (1 download); M343111 (1 download); M343209 (1 download); M343211 (1 download); M342550 (1 download); M342553 (1 download); M342556 (1 download); M342570 (1 download); M342559 (1 download); M342561 (1 download); M342565 (1 download); M342568 (1 download); M342571 (1 download); M342581 (1 download); M344011 (1 download); M381629 (1 download); M379498 (1 download); M340788 (1 download); M340790 (1 download); M340832 (1 download); M343531 (1 download);