Project 223: S. T. Williams, K. M. Donald, H. G. Spencer, T. Nakano. 2010. Molecular systematics of the marine gastropod families Trochidae and Calliostomatidae (Mollusca: Superfamily Trochoidea). Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution. 54 (3):783-809.
Specimen: Monilea smithi (Wood, 1828) (NSMT:Mo76842)


This study is the most extensive molecular study of the gastropod families Trochidae and Calliostomatidae published to date, in terms of both numbers of taxa and of gene sequences. As a result of Bayesian phylogenetic analyses of molecular sequence data from one nuclear gene and three mitochondrial genes, we propose dramatic changes to Trochidae family systematics, present the first molecular phylogeny for Calliostomatidae and include the first published sequence data for the enigmatic subfamily Thysanodontinae. Our phylogeny demonstrates that within the family Trochidae there is strong support for three subfamilies new to traditional classifications: Alcyninae subfam. nov., Fossarininae and Chrysostomatinae subfam. nov. As proposed, Alcyninae consists only of the nominotypical genus Alcyna, which is sister to all other trochids. The subfamily Fossarininae, as defined here, includes Fossarina, Broderipia, Synaptocochlea and ‘‘Roya” eximia and probably also Clydonochilus and Minopa. The subfamily Chrysostomatinae comprises the genera Chrysostoma and Chlorodiloma. Additional molecular support is also obtained for recently redefined Trochinae, Monodontinae, and Cantharidinae and for the traditionally recognised subfamilies Umboniinae and Stomatellinae. The subfamily Lirulariinae is not supported by the molecular data, but rather is incorporated into Umboniinae. We also demonstrate that the current concept of the subfamily Margaritinae (previously a trochid subfamily, but recently and provisionally assigned to Turbinidae) is not monophyletic. We provide preliminary evidence that whereas Margarella rosea (previously a member of Margaritinae) belongs in the trochid subfamily Cantharidinae, its presumptive congener M. antarctica is not a trochid, but instead clusters with the thysanodontine genus Carinastele. Based on the phylogenetic placement of C. kristelleae, we agree with previous proposals based on morphological data that Thysanodontinae are more closely related to Calliostomatidae than Trochidae. Both Calliostoma and Carinastele are carnivorous and if a sister relationship can be confirmed between Carinastele and Margarella antarctica it might mean that carnivory evolved twice in Trochoidea. The direction of dietary changes was not investigated in this study, but mapping diet onto the phylogeny suggests that true herbivory is predominantly a derived character. The new classification system also means that five trochid subfamilies are predominantly associated with hard substrata, one with soft substrata (Umboniinae) and two with algae and seagrass (Alcyninae and Cantharidinae). There has been a shift back to hard substrata in one umboniine clade. Two of three clades within Calliostomatidae were predominantly associated with hard substrata, but one Japanese clade is associated with sand. The finding of three new, unidentified species from very deep water means that Trochidae, like Calliostomatidae, now includes species found at bathyal depths. More deep-water species may be found as increased sampling leads to the discovery of new species.

Read the article »

Project DOI: 10.7934/P223,
This project contains
  • 126 Media
  • 1 Document
  • 119 Taxa
  • 136 Specimens
Total size of project's media files: 150.86M

Download Project SDD File
Currently Viewing:
MorphoBank Project 223

    Authors' Institutions

    • Natural History Museum, London

    • University of Otago

    • National Museum of Nature and Science, Japan


    member name taxa specimens media media
    Suzanne Williams
    Project Administrator
    MorphoBank Curator
    Full membership
    Kirsten Donald
    Full membership
    Tomo Nakano
    Full membership

    Project has no matrices defined.

    Project views

    type number of views Individual items viewed (where applicable)
    Total project views177169
    Media views70938M24198 (610 views); M24568 (517 views); M24486 (661 views); M24197 (578 views); Media search (6986 views); M24490 (517 views); M24598 (329 views); M24522 (501 views); M24520 (496 views); M24585 (503 views); M24264 (575 views); M24109 (774 views); M24603 (335 views); M24543 (552 views); M24105 (674 views); M24077 (816 views); M24078 (577 views); M24534 (509 views); M24217 (610 views); M24281 (550 views); M24759 (353 views); M24516 (570 views); M24521 (526 views); M24487 (558 views); M24518 (528 views); M24492 (477 views); M24491 (505 views); M24218 (560 views); M24582 (531 views); M33710 (361 views); M25184 (319 views); M24944 (338 views); M24948 (282 views); M24601 (389 views); M24530 (502 views); M24275 (555 views); M24106 (764 views); M24107 (504 views); M24196 (694 views); M24215 (532 views); M24219 (854 views); M24248 (793 views); M24249 (580 views); M24513 (709 views); M24279 (589 views); M24510 (487 views); M24523 (468 views); M24558 (472 views); M24562 (509 views); M24110 (549 views); M24536 (560 views); M24247 (582 views); M24199 (530 views); M24597 (381 views); M24533 (452 views); M24283 (501 views); M24604 (343 views); M24282 (571 views); M24579 (535 views); M24760 (327 views); M24271 (533 views); M24554 (513 views); M24267 (529 views); M24527 (467 views); M24273 (503 views); M24940 (380 views); M24941 (360 views); M24942 (343 views); M24943 (363 views); M24572 (493 views); M24277 (626 views); M24576 (523 views); M24569 (525 views); M24525 (482 views); M24265 (522 views); M24557 (503 views); M24591 (510 views); M24559 (490 views); M24593 (356 views); M24546 (471 views); M24577 (526 views); M24584 (516 views); M24493 (539 views); M24268 (532 views); M24269 (535 views); M24278 (620 views); M24563 (468 views); M24581 (481 views); M24514 (536 views); M24272 (558 views); M24561 (507 views); M24111 (733 views); M24495 (593 views); M24588 (495 views); M24544 (509 views); M24488 (532 views); M24578 (490 views); M24511 (497 views); M24555 (492 views); M24489 (456 views); M24590 (587 views); M24595 (333 views); M24571 (524 views); M24596 (344 views); M24539 (549 views); M24599 (319 views); M24509 (535 views); M24524 (533 views); M24758 (333 views); M24761 (316 views); M24519 (500 views); M24276 (607 views); M24280 (551 views); M24482 (623 views); M24270 (519 views); M24266 (566 views); M24494 (622 views); M24552 (530 views); M24583 (505 views); M24586 (478 views); M24580 (476 views); M24685 (351 views); M24587 (518 views); M24600 (319 views); M24592 (282 views); M24594 (350 views); M33388 (351 views);
    Specimen list79090
    Taxon list20253
    Project overview4549
    Documents list1278

    Project downloads

    type number of downloads Individual items downloaded (where applicable)
    Total downloads from project355
    Media downloads15M24568 (1 download); M24217 (1 download); M24196 (1 download); M24948 (1 download); M24111 (1 download); M24249 (1 download); M24595 (2 downloads); M24596 (1 download); M24486 (1 download); M24539 (2 downloads); M24105 (1 download); M24533 (1 download); M24110 (1 download);
    Document downloads4Copyright information for exemplar media (4 downloads);
    Project downloads336