Project 530: R. W. Boessenecker, M. Churchill. 2013. A Reevaluation of the Morphology, Paleoecology, and Phylogenetic Relationships of the Enigmatic Walrus Pelagiarctos. PLOS ONE. 8 (1):e54311.
Specimen: † Pelagiarctos sp. (SDNHM/uncatalogued)

Abstract

Background
A number of aberrant walruses (Odobenidae) have been described from the Neogene of the North Pacific, including specialized suction-feeding and generalist fish-eating taxa. At least one of these fossil walruses has been hypothesized to have been a specialized predator of other marine mammals, the middle Miocene walrus Pelagiarctos thomasi from the Sharktooth Hill Bonebed of California (16.1–14.5 Ma).
Methodology/Principal Findings
A new specimen of Pelagiarctos from the middle Miocene “Topanga” Formation of southern California (17.5–15 Ma) allows a reassessment of the morphology and feeding ecology of this extinct walrus. The mandibles of this new specimen are robust with large canines, bulbous premolars with prominent paraconid, metaconid, hypoconid cusps, crenulated lingual cingula with small talonid basins, M2 present, double-rooted P3–M1, single-rooted P1 and M2, and a P2 with a bilobate root. Because this specimen lacks a fused mandibular symphysis like Pelagiarctos thomasi, it is instead referred to Pelagiarctos sp. This specimen is more informative than the fragmentary holotype of Pelagiarctos thomasi, permitting Pelagiarctos to be included within a phylogenetic analysis for the first time. Analysis of a matrix composed of 90 cranial, dental, mandibular and postcranial characters indicates that Pelagiarctos is an early diverging walrus and sister to the late Miocene walrus Imagotaria downsi. We reevaluate the evidence for a macropredatory lifestyle for Pelagiarctos, and we find no evidence of specialization towards a macrophagous diet, suggesting that Pelagiarctos was a generalist feeder with the ability to feed on large prey.
Conclusions/Significance
This new specimen of Pelagiarctos adds to the knowledge of this problematic taxon. The phylogenetic analysis conclusively demonstrates that Pelagiarctos is an early diverging walrus. Pelagiarctos does not show morphological specializations associated with macrophagy, and was likely a generalist predator, feeding on fish, invertebrates, and the occasional warm-blooded prey item.


Read the article »

Project DOI: 10.7934/P530, http://dx.doi.org/10.7934/P530
This project containsMatrices
  • 624 Media
  • 2 Matrices
  • 1 Document
  • 27 Taxa
  • 36 Specimens
  • 90 Characters
Total size of project's media files: 1.18G

Download Project SDD File
Total scored cells: 2432
Total media associated with cells: 581
Total labels associated with cell media: 556
Characters
Total characters: 129
Total characters with associated media: 0
Total characters with media with labels: 0
Total character states: 249
Total character states with associated media: 79
Total character states with media with labels:79
Total unordered/ordered characters:129/0
Currently Viewing:
MorphoBank Project 530

    This research
    supported by

    Authors' Institutions

    • University of Otago

    • University of Wyoming



    Members

    member name taxa specimens media chars character
    media
    labels
    cell scorings
    (scored, NPA, "-")
    cell
    medialabels
    rules
    Morgan Churchill
    Project Administrator
    Last logged in 01/16/13
    2424527957202026
    (2026, 0, 0)
    2232000
    Robert Boessenecker
    Full membership
    Last logged in 11/07/12
    312973488156406
    (406, 0, 0)
    3583560


    Taxonomic Overview for Matrix 'M1174' (20 Taxa)

    taxon unscored
    cells
    scored
    cells
    no cell
    support
    NPA
    cells
    "-" cellscell images labels on
    cell images
    member
    access
    [1] † Enaliarctos emlongi
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    03970031242
    [2] † Pteronarctos goedertae
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    039110027272
    [3] † Desmatophoca oregonensis
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    03950033312
    [4] † Allodesmus gracilis
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    039120027262
    [5] Monachus monachus
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    03940035332
    [6] Erignathus barbatus
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    04160033312
    [7] Callorhinus ursinus
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    13860032302
    [8] † Proneotherium repenningi
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    03960037362
    [9] † Kamtschatarctos sinelnikovae
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    93050025242
    [10] † Neotherium mirum
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    0393100662
    [11] † Imagotaria downsi
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    04440058562
    [12] † Pelagiarctos sp.
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    53420033332
    [13] † Pontolis magnus
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    1383700002
    [14] † Gomphotaria pugnax
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    53440028282
    [15] † Dusignathus santacruzensis
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    03940034372
    [16] † Dusignathus seftoni
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    73350025252
    [17] † Protodobenus japonicus
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    13830033312
    [18] † Ontocetus emmonsi
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    13830037372
    [19] † Valenictus chulavistensis
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    192060014132
    [20] Odobenus rosmarus
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    23740033282


    Taxonomic Overview for Matrix 'M1891' (23 Taxa)

    taxon unscored
    cells
    scored
    cells
    no cell
    support
    NPA
    cells
    "-" cellscell images labels on
    cell images
    member
    access
    [1] † Enaliarctos emlongi
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    8828000002
    [2] † Pteronarctos goedertae
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    8828100002
    [3] Callorhinus ursinus
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    1898900002
    [4] † Desmatophoca oregonensis
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    6868300002
    [5] † Allodesmus gracilis
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    0929000002
    [6] Erignathus barbatus
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    0929000002
    [7] Monachus monachus
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    0909000002
    [8] † Prototaria primigenia
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    47434300002
    [9] † Proneotherium repenningi
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    8828100002
    [10] † Neotherium mirum
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    1898700002
    [11] † Kamtschatarctos sinelnikovae
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    49414000002
    [12] † Pseudotaria muramotoi
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    54363600002
    [13] † Imagotaria downsi
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    1968800002
    [14] † Pelagiarctos sp.
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    56343300002
    [15] † Pontolis magnus
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    3878600002
    [16] † Dusignathus santacruzensis
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    35555300002
    [17] † Dusignathus seftoni
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    16767000002
    [18] † Gomphotaria pugnax
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    13777400002
    [19] Aivukus cedrosensis
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    32585800002
    [20] † Protodobenus japonicus
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    26646100002
    [21] † Ontocetus emmonsi
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    2888700002
    [22] † Valenictus chulavistensis
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    22686800002
    [23] Odobenus rosmarus
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    2888800002


    Project views

    type number of views Individual items viewed (where applicable)
    Total project views136511
    Project overview4095
    Matrix views2714Matrix landing page (2130 views); Kohno 2006 modified matrix (303 views); walrus mandible and lower dentition (281 views);
    Media views90351Media search (6475 views); M86601 (416 views); M86654 (385 views); M86662 (424 views); M86648 (453 views); M101358 (309 views); M148227 (9 views); M86643 (427 views); M86669 (433 views); M86655 (372 views); M86221 (402 views); M148428 (6 views); M86649 (383 views); M86656 (382 views); M93589 (508 views); M86598 (412 views); M148291 (8 views); M86657 (421 views); M86674 (370 views); M86647 (374 views); M86652 (419 views); M86653 (403 views); M86644 (422 views); M107639 (36 views); M86720 (430 views); M86719 (422 views); M101444 (276 views); M101426 (304 views); M101435 (238 views); M107650 (37 views); M93595 (213 views); M93594 (213 views); M93593 (222 views); M93592 (212 views); M93591 (225 views); M93590 (396 views); M93580 (337 views); M86730 (377 views); M101348 (285 views); M148322 (9 views); M101345 (335 views); M101391 (323 views); M101452 (291 views); M101416 (355 views); M101447 (275 views); M101428 (283 views); M101338 (299 views); M101342 (329 views); M148289 (9 views); M148299 (11 views); M148298 (10 views); M148309 (12 views); M148313 (9 views); M148317 (5 views); M148321 (16 views); M101441 (247 views); M101449 (235 views); M148212 (14 views); M101377 (325 views); M101343 (303 views); M101423 (308 views); M101421 (314 views); M101379 (311 views); M86732 (399 views); M101334 (305 views); M106621 (34 views); M101396 (286 views); M101335 (299 views); M101353 (274 views); M101403 (284 views); M101431 (307 views); M101356 (327 views); M106613 (61 views); M101434 (177 views); M101436 (221 views); M101440 (200 views); M101445 (212 views); M101446 (297 views); M101448 (233 views); M101450 (231 views); M101451 (204 views); M101453 (248 views); M101433 (339 views); M101420 (313 views); M107658 (33 views); M101336 (320 views); M101337 (322 views); M101339 (319 views); M101340 (352 views); M101341 (300 views); M101344 (310 views); M101346 (284 views); M101347 (326 views); M101349 (337 views); M101350 (283 views); M101351 (296 views); M101352 (297 views); M101354 (302 views); M101355 (310 views); M101357 (360 views); M101359 (342 views); M101360 (329 views); M101361 (343 views); M101362 (380 views); M101363 (308 views); M101364 (327 views); M101365 (368 views); M101366 (340 views); M101367 (320 views); M101368 (298 views); M101369 (304 views); M101370 (401 views); M101371 (328 views); M101372 (348 views); M101373 (349 views); M101374 (362 views); M101375 (323 views); M101376 (342 views); M101378 (292 views); M101380 (279 views); M101381 (286 views); M101382 (386 views); M101383 (310 views); M101384 (337 views); M101385 (329 views); M101386 (327 views); M101387 (320 views); M101388 (322 views); M101389 (334 views); M101390 (284 views); M101392 (317 views); M101393 (316 views); M101394 (344 views); M101395 (369 views); M101397 (316 views); M101398 (336 views); M101399 (237 views); M101400 (274 views); M101401 (277 views); M101402 (322 views); M101404 (404 views); M101405 (311 views); M101406 (337 views); M101407 (313 views); M101408 (337 views); M101409 (340 views); M101410 (300 views); M101411 (346 views); M101412 (289 views); M101413 (337 views); M101414 (328 views); M101415 (321 views); M101417 (344 views); M101418 (337 views); M101419 (281 views); M101422 (317 views); M101424 (335 views); M101425 (330 views); M101427 (289 views); M101429 (325 views); M101430 (323 views); M101432 (320 views); M101437 (217 views); M101438 (262 views); M101439 (184 views); M101442 (229 views); M101443 (195 views); M107688 (44 views); M107642 (34 views); M86708 (334 views); M86684 (391 views); M86709 (375 views); M148204 (16 views); M107680 (61 views); M107661 (49 views); M107643 (44 views); M107668 (52 views); M107690 (61 views); M86699 (430 views); M86711 (354 views); M106633 (31 views); M107637 (39 views); M107672 (35 views); M106630 (47 views); M107683 (44 views); M106625 (30 views); M148293 (13 views); M107671 (46 views); M86645 (414 views); M86678 (420 views); M107685 (44 views); M106620 (41 views); M106614 (51 views); M86722 (359 views); M86681 (378 views); M106618 (37 views); M148189 (14 views); M86666 (410 views); M107689 (69 views); M106626 (45 views); M93584 (408 views); M86696 (392 views); M107636 (37 views); M107646 (45 views); M106611 (57 views); M107684 (40 views); M148318 (6 views); M148325 (8 views); M148338 (15 views); M86659 (388 views); M107657 (32 views); M86663 (424 views); M107673 (41 views); M101459 (33 views); M107647 (33 views); M106627 (35 views); M101468 (59 views); M148304 (7 views); M148358 (8 views); M86698 (371 views); M107651 (35 views); M107681 (44 views); M86688 (412 views); M86650 (437 views); M86665 (369 views); M86670 (354 views); M86668 (388 views); M86677 (418 views); M106634 (30 views); M86661 (441 views); M86673 (376 views); M107692 (44 views); M101464 (56 views); M101465 (33 views); M86671 (405 views); M106615 (87 views); M107676 (112 views); M86721 (381 views); M101469 (70 views); M106631 (35 views); M106617 (35 views); M86703 (373 views); M86728 (368 views); M107667 (52 views); M86642 (390 views); M86651 (384 views); M86700 (405 views); M86701 (382 views); M86702 (376 views); M86704 (401 views); M86705 (388 views); M86706 (367 views); M86707 (345 views); M86724 (469 views); M86725 (361 views); M86726 (396 views); M93581 (385 views); M93582 (365 views); M93583 (411 views); M93585 (397 views); M93586 (379 views); M93587 (409 views); M93588 (404 views); M86731 (417 views); M86600 (423 views); M86646 (410 views); M86660 (432 views); M86664 (401 views); M86667 (362 views); M86679 (395 views); M86680 (379 views); M86682 (368 views); M86683 (416 views); M86685 (398 views); M86686 (347 views); M86687 (358 views); M86689 (373 views); M86694 (448 views); M86695 (424 views); M86727 (402 views); M86729 (410 views); M86733 (375 views); M107677 (54 views); M107687 (44 views); M148283 (11 views); M107669 (53 views); M106619 (40 views); M107679 (43 views); M86672 (425 views); M86675 (412 views); M86676 (384 views); M86710 (372 views); M86713 (381 views); M86714 (348 views); M86718 (392 views); M86723 (361 views); M107648 (35 views); M148264 (7 views); M107634 (47 views); M107670 (92 views); M107662 (33 views); M148203 (15 views); M148240 (13 views); M148229 (13 views); M107702 (6 views); M148219 (5 views); M101460 (89 views); M107691 (50 views); M106610 (30 views); M106612 (52 views); M106616 (44 views); M106622 (34 views); M106623 (44 views); M106624 (33 views); M106628 (29 views); M106629 (44 views); M106632 (33 views); M106635 (28 views); M106636 (31 views); M106637 (45 views); M107653 (49 views); M101457 (49 views); M148417 (4 views); M148369 (5 views); M148233 (13 views); M148403 (4 views); M86717 (379 views); M107652 (36 views); M107644 (33 views); M107664 (38 views); M86716 (430 views); M101463 (53 views); M107665 (36 views); M101458 (47 views); M107633 (24 views); M107635 (44 views); M107638 (31 views); M107645 (36 views); M107649 (32 views); M107654 (50 views); M107655 (31 views); M107656 (39 views); M107659 (32 views); M107660 (32 views); M107663 (39 views); M107666 (46 views); M107674 (42 views); M107675 (33 views); M148327 (5 views); M107640 (35 views); M107641 (33 views); M107678 (30 views); M107682 (36 views); M107686 (53 views); M101470 (44 views); M101461 (50 views); M148197 (5 views); M101454 (42 views); M101455 (36 views); M101456 (44 views); M101462 (71 views); M101466 (53 views); M101467 (28 views); M148279 (6 views); M148266 (5 views); M148273 (5 views); M148281 (5 views); M148336 (4 views); M148251 (5 views); M148320 (6 views); M148285 (6 views); M148476 (11 views); M148370 (6 views); M86715 (401 views); M148411 (4 views); M107703 (11 views); M148355 (4 views); M148246 (12 views); M148250 (5 views); M148295 (6 views); M107698 (13 views); M148422 (3 views); M148282 (8 views); M148372 (5 views); M148371 (3 views); M148232 (14 views); M148466 (11 views); M148462 (8 views); M148396 (4 views); M148296 (6 views); M148190 (14 views); M148201 (14 views); M148288 (6 views); M148359 (4 views); M148418 (9 views); M148414 (4 views); M148300 (6 views); M148455 (11 views); M148277 (5 views); M148471 (7 views); M148188 (4 views); M148335 (6 views); M148334 (10 views); M148328 (6 views); M148310 (6 views); M148305 (5 views); M148218 (4 views); M148392 (4 views); M148444 (5 views); M148395 (5 views); M148375 (6 views); M148380 (6 views); M148376 (5 views); M148445 (4 views); M148389 (4 views); M148217 (3 views); M148337 (5 views); M148453 (3 views); M148187 (4 views); M148432 (9 views); M148440 (3 views); M148193 (15 views); M148276 (7 views); M148208 (12 views); M148443 (7 views); M148252 (6 views); M148228 (9 views); M107695 (9 views); M148362 (3 views); M148231 (11 views); M107697 (6 views); M148191 (12 views); M148449 (4 views); M148357 (4 views); M148260 (5 views); M148353 (3 views); M148424 (3 views); M148280 (4 views); M148456 (8 views); M148377 (5 views); M148195 (13 views); M148351 (4 views); M148226 (11 views); M148378 (5 views); M148454 (6 views); M148211 (3 views); M148404 (5 views); M148384 (3 views); M148235 (3 views); M148312 (4 views); M148457 (6 views); M148326 (6 views); M148248 (5 views); M148421 (4 views); M148434 (3 views); M148397 (3 views); M148215 (11 views); M148361 (2 views); M148294 (7 views); M148323 (5 views); M148430 (4 views); M148415 (4 views); M148290 (5 views); M148436 (4 views); M148216 (13 views); M148465 (7 views); M148393 (20 views); M148477 (10 views); M148441 (7 views); M148249 (6 views); M148413 (4 views); M148194 (11 views); M148381 (3 views); M148347 (3 views); M148416 (12 views); M148368 (4 views); M148461 (5 views); M148350 (5 views); M107693 (17 views); M148245 (12 views); M148200 (6 views); M148448 (4 views); M148223 (12 views); M148374 (3 views); M107699 (13 views); M148255 (4 views); M148267 (5 views); M148382 (4 views); M148330 (6 views); M148206 (13 views); M148447 (3 views); M148341 (6 views); M148354 (3 views); M148460 (6 views); M148213 (4 views); M148442 (5 views); M148367 (4 views); M148315 (7 views); M148429 (4 views); M148261 (6 views); M148275 (5 views); M148329 (8 views); M148307 (7 views); M148437 (3 views); M148463 (7 views); M148242 (4 views); M148287 (6 views); M148352 (3 views); M148324 (5 views); M148364 (4 views); M148258 (4 views); M148234 (14 views); M148423 (3 views); M148450 (6 views); M148303 (6 views); M148365 (3 views); M148247 (5 views); M148446 (3 views); M148214 (12 views); M148237 (4 views); M148205 (15 views); M148272 (9 views); M148311 (5 views); M148475 (7 views); M148363 (3 views); M107694 (5 views); M148230 (7 views); M148210 (12 views); M148302 (7 views); M148427 (3 views); M148472 (7 views); M148346 (4 views); M148394 (2 views); M148349 (3 views); M148221 (5 views); M107700 (7 views); M148222 (16 views); M148405 (8 views); M148316 (11 views); M148306 (6 views); M148225 (5 views); M148297 (6 views); M148257 (5 views); M148253 (4 views); M148278 (5 views); M148269 (5 views); M148199 (12 views); M148391 (5 views); M148348 (4 views); M148343 (11 views); M148340 (4 views); M148209 (15 views); M148387 (2 views); M148198 (4 views); M148409 (2 views); M148241 (5 views); M148333 (5 views); M148243 (5 views); M148301 (6 views); M148344 (5 views); M148431 (3 views); M148262 (7 views); M148331 (6 views); M148274 (5 views); M148224 (15 views); M148356 (2 views); M148292 (6 views); M148286 (5 views); M148464 (6 views); M148236 (6 views); M148220 (5 views); M148388 (2 views); M148401 (2 views); M107701 (6 views); M148196 (4 views); M148468 (11 views); M148254 (7 views); M148319 (5 views); M148410 (3 views); M148470 (7 views); M148314 (5 views); M148459 (12 views); M148345 (5 views); M148271 (5 views); M148192 (12 views); M148259 (4 views); M148268 (7 views); M148383 (2 views); M148469 (6 views); M148385 (2 views); M148402 (4 views); M148458 (10 views); M148386 (3 views); M148239 (12 views); M148412 (4 views); M148435 (2 views); M148474 (6 views); M148373 (5 views); M148270 (6 views); M148263 (5 views); M148439 (3 views); M148398 (2 views); M148400 (3 views); M148238 (13 views); M148244 (10 views); M148360 (2 views); M148473 (9 views); M148366 (5 views); M148332 (6 views); M148265 (9 views); M148207 (7 views); M148408 (4 views); M148399 (2 views); M148426 (4 views); M148420 (3 views); M148433 (2 views); M148390 (2 views); M148467 (7 views); M107696 (15 views); M148202 (14 views); M148256 (6 views); M148339 (4 views); M148284 (5 views); M148342 (3 views); M148308 (7 views);
    Specimen list22146
    Documents list1718
    Taxon list11914
    Bibliography3573




    Project downloads

    type number of downloads Individual items downloaded (where applicable)
    Total downloads from project374
    Matrix downloads60Kohno 2006 modified matrix (36 downloads); walrus mandible and lower dentition (24 downloads);
    Project downloads256
    Document downloads7 (7 downloads);
    Media downloads51M86722 (2 downloads); M93595 (1 download); M93594 (1 download); M93593 (1 download); M93592 (1 download); M93591 (2 downloads); M93590 (1 download); M93589 (2 downloads); M93580 (1 download); M86649 (1 download); M86671 (1 download); M86669 (1 download); M86674 (1 download); M86221 (1 download); M101349 (1 download); M101352 (1 download); M101358 (1 download); M101356 (1 download); M101374 (1 download); M101377 (1 download); M101385 (1 download); M101382 (1 download); M101390 (2 downloads); M101393 (1 download); M101411 (1 download); M106613 (1 download); M106618 (1 download); M106628 (1 download); M148289 (1 download); M148294 (1 download); M148309 (1 download); M148308 (1 download); M148321 (1 download); M148343 (1 download); M86642 (1 download); M86600 (1 download); M86643 (1 download); M86645 (1 download); M86598 (1 download); M86648 (1 download); M86651 (1 download); M86652 (1 download); M86653 (1 download); M86654 (1 download); M86655 (1 download); M86656 (1 download); M86657 (1 download);