Project 470: E. G. Ekdale, A. Berta, T. A. Deméré. 2011. The Comparative Osteology of the Petrotympanic Complex (Ear Region) of Extant Baleen Whales (Cetacea: Mysticeti). PLOS ONE. 6 (6):e21311.
Specimen: Balaenoptera acutorostrata (SDNHM/23642)

Abstract

Anatomical comparisons of the ear region of baleen whales (Mysticeti) are provided through detailed osteological descriptions and high-resolution photographs of the petrotympanic complex (tympanic bulla and petrosal bone) of all extant species of mysticete cetaceans. Salient morphological features are illustrated and identified, including overall shape of the bulla, size of the conical process of the bulla, morphology of the promontorium, and the size and shape of the anterior process of the petrosal. We place our comparative osteological observations into a phylogenetic context in order to initiate an exploration into petrotympanic evolution within Mysticeti.

Principal Findings

The morphology of the petrotympanic complex is diagnostic for individual species of baleen whale (e.g., sigmoid and conical processes positioned at midline of bulla in Balaenoptera musculus ; confluence of fenestra cochleae and perilymphatic foramen in Eschrichtius robustus ), and several mysticete clades are united by derived characteristics. Balaenids and neobalaenids share derived features of the bulla, such as a rhomboid shape and a reduced anterior lobe (swelling) in ventral aspect, and eschrichtiids share derived morphologies of the petrosal with balaenopterids, including loss of a medial promontory groove and dorsomedial elongation of the promontorium. Monophyly of Balaenoidea (Balaenidae and Neobalaenidae) and Balaenopteroidea (Balaenopteridae and Eschrichtiidae) was recovered in phylogenetic analyses utilizing data exclusively from the petrotympanic complex.

Significance

This study fills a major gap in our knowledge of the complex structures of the mysticete petrotympanic complex, which is an important anatomical region for the interpretation of the evolutionary history of mammals. In addition, we introduce a novel body of phylogenetically informative characters from the ear region of mysticetes. Our detailed anatomical descriptions, illustrations, and comparisons provide valuable data for current and future studies on the phylogenetic relationships, evolution, and auditory physiology of mysticetes and other cetaceans throughout Earth's history.



Read the article »

Project DOI: 10.7934/P470, http://dx.doi.org/10.7934/P470
This project containsMatrices
  • 599 Media
  • 1 Matrix
  • 7 Documents
  • 15 Taxa
  • 171 Specimens
  • 48 Characters
Total size of project's media files: 661 MB

Download Project SDD File
Total scored cells: 642
Total media associated with cells: 893
Total labels associated with cell media: 928
Characters
Total characters: 48
Total characters with associated media: 1
Total characters with media with labels: 1
Total character states: 114
Total character states with associated media: 101
Total character states with media with labels:101
Total unordered/ordered characters:48/0
Currently Viewing:
MorphoBank Project 470

    This research
    supported by

    Authors' Institutions

    • San Diego State University

    • San Diego Natural History Museum



    Members

    member name taxa specimens media chars character
    media
    labels
    cell scorings
    (scored, NPA, "-")
    cell
    notes  medialabels
    rules
    Tom Demere
    Project Administrator
    Last logged in 06/22/11
    00102112
    (12, 0, 0)
    124240
    Annalisa Berta
    Full membership
    Last logged in 02/24/11
    0000000
    (0, 0, 0)
    0000
    MorphoBank Curator
    Full membership
    Last logged in 08/07/14
    0000000
    (0, 0, 0)
    0000
    Eric Ekdale
    Full membership
    Last logged in 07/11/11
    1145539084554
    (554, 0, 0)
    12726710


    Taxonomic Overview for Matrix 'M1060' (14 Taxa)

    taxon unscored
    cells
    scored
    cells
    no cell
    support
    NPA
    cells
    "-" cellscell images labels on
    cell images
    member
    access
    [1] † Mammalodon colliveri
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    153300024224
    [2] † Eomysticetus whitmorei
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    133500065654
    [3] Balaenoptera acutorostrata
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    04800059624
    [4] Balaenoptera bonaerensis
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    04800064674
    [5] Balaenoptera borealis
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    05000070724
    [6] Balaenoptera edeni
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    04800073714
    [7] Balaenoptera musculus
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    04900072784
    [8] Balaenoptera omurai
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    64200057624
    [9] Balaenoptera physalus
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    24900064684
    [10] Megaptera novaeangliae
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    14900082854
    [11] Eschrichtius robustus
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    04900070724
    [12] Caperea marginata
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    44400063634
    [13] Balaena mysticetus
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    04900068764
    [14] Eubalaena sp.
    Last Modified in 12/05/13
    04900062654


    Project views

    type number of views Individual items viewed (where applicable)
    Total project views153298
    Media views70450Media search (4300 views); M62634 (459 views); M62580 (455 views); M62596 (445 views); M62663 (431 views); M63827 (9 views); M63828 (6 views); M63829 (6 views); M63830 (8 views); M62597 (420 views); M62602 (588 views); M62631 (415 views); M62654 (596 views); M62636 (420 views); M65344 (6 views); M62598 (681 views); M62681 (425 views); M63393 (9 views); M66841 (20 views); M66845 (11 views); M63470 (7 views); M65280 (5 views); M65352 (6 views); M63541 (8 views); M64264 (7 views); M62996 (147 views); M62661 (395 views); M62635 (491 views); M62711 (354 views); M62679 (474 views); M67361 (11 views); M67374 (12 views); M62665 (412 views); M62693 (395 views); M65686 (12 views); M67371 (13 views); M65762 (12 views); M66796 (11 views); M66284 (13 views); M66044 (11 views); M62701 (434 views); M62724 (403 views); M62673 (407 views); M62637 (609 views); M62737 (367 views); M62723 (394 views); M62685 (388 views); M62828 (165 views); M62775 (186 views); M62769 (153 views); M62718 (376 views); M62687 (411 views); M62730 (383 views); M62722 (442 views); M62706 (391 views); M62677 (462 views); M62708 (387 views); M62686 (383 views); M62727 (434 views); M62695 (412 views); M62678 (437 views); M62599 (402 views); M62803 (166 views); M62768 (159 views); M62773 (205 views); M62774 (150 views); M62776 (173 views); M62777 (170 views); M62778 (153 views); M62779 (162 views); M62780 (181 views); M62781 (181 views); M62782 (139 views); M62783 (166 views); M62784 (164 views); M62785 (180 views); M62786 (179 views); M62787 (160 views); M62788 (178 views); M62789 (167 views); M62790 (172 views); M62791 (187 views); M62792 (146 views); M62793 (141 views); M62794 (164 views); M62795 (176 views); M62796 (163 views); M62797 (149 views); M62798 (243 views); M62799 (172 views); M62800 (170 views); M62801 (186 views); M62802 (152 views); M62804 (142 views); M62805 (152 views); M62806 (207 views); M62807 (133 views); M62808 (169 views); M62809 (152 views); M62810 (168 views); M62811 (199 views); M62812 (164 views); M62813 (160 views); M62814 (142 views); M62815 (188 views); M62816 (160 views); M62817 (165 views); M62818 (201 views); M62819 (178 views); M62820 (175 views); M62821 (167 views); M62822 (175 views); M62823 (139 views); M62824 (180 views); M62825 (170 views); M62826 (133 views); M62827 (155 views); M62829 (183 views); M62830 (142 views); M62831 (140 views); M62832 (153 views); M62833 (169 views); M62834 (195 views); M62835 (257 views); M62836 (167 views); M62734 (414 views); M62652 (420 views); M62736 (414 views); M62700 (387 views); M62704 (457 views); M62739 (427 views); M62670 (431 views); M62671 (444 views); M62688 (432 views); M62600 (427 views); M62733 (414 views); M62715 (388 views); M62638 (547 views); M62747 (174 views); M62847 (146 views); M62848 (174 views); M62849 (161 views); M62850 (150 views); M62851 (146 views); M62852 (156 views); M62853 (183 views); M62854 (156 views); M62855 (172 views); M62680 (438 views); M62674 (439 views); M62707 (414 views); M62837 (167 views); M62838 (184 views); M62839 (164 views); M62840 (176 views); M62841 (160 views); M62842 (166 views); M62843 (155 views); M62844 (156 views); M62845 (184 views); M62846 (171 views); M62738 (409 views); M62731 (370 views); M62676 (432 views); M62689 (394 views); M62713 (389 views); M62684 (382 views); M62771 (164 views); M62772 (167 views); M62752 (163 views); M62709 (431 views); M62749 (175 views); M62926 (169 views); M62717 (393 views); M62748 (160 views); M62682 (381 views); M62760 (194 views); M62745 (170 views); M62712 (426 views); M62714 (412 views); M62698 (405 views); M62668 (392 views); M62735 (361 views); M62675 (456 views); M62694 (393 views); M62702 (428 views); M62729 (390 views); M62725 (432 views); M62728 (403 views); M62710 (372 views); M62763 (160 views); M62653 (548 views); M65283 (9 views); M62703 (413 views); M62726 (374 views); M62721 (415 views); M62633 (423 views); M62664 (472 views); M62696 (425 views); M62666 (418 views); M62705 (458 views); M62630 (585 views); M62699 (428 views); M62690 (407 views); M62691 (428 views); M62692 (365 views); M62697 (431 views); M62716 (429 views); M62719 (396 views); M62720 (435 views); M62732 (365 views); M62601 (569 views); M62632 (401 views); M62660 (424 views); M62662 (432 views); M62667 (419 views); M62669 (379 views); M62672 (458 views); M62683 (396 views); M62741 (150 views); M63725 (9 views); M62861 (180 views); M63596 (6 views); M62860 (148 views); M63704 (5 views); M63201 (3 views); M62754 (173 views); M62950 (152 views); M66293 (10 views); M63755 (6 views); M63787 (5 views); M65251 (7 views); M65232 (5 views); M65249 (6 views); M63074 (15 views); M66838 (12 views); M63863 (18 views); M62740 (160 views); M63182 (7 views); M65327 (9 views); M62743 (203 views); M62755 (138 views); M62757 (169 views); M62758 (149 views); M62765 (166 views); M62744 (161 views); M62759 (162 views); M62751 (147 views); M62859 (155 views); M62857 (134 views); M62858 (150 views); M62856 (151 views); M65292 (5 views); M62742 (166 views); M62746 (179 views); M62750 (164 views); M62753 (164 views); M62756 (156 views); M62761 (229 views); M62762 (211 views); M62764 (184 views); M62766 (180 views); M62767 (170 views); M62770 (145 views); M67981 (12 views); M65312 (4 views); M67368 (11 views); M65304 (4 views); M65230 (4 views); M63858 (6 views); M63777 (6 views); M63860 (11 views); M65277 (4 views); M65760 (11 views); M65306 (3 views); M63849 (5 views); M65315 (4 views); M63821 (9 views); M66046 (10 views); M63751 (6 views); M65346 (4 views); M65324 (3 views); M63601 (5 views); M68020 (10 views); M63857 (5 views); M63868 (4 views); M66048 (13 views); M66795 (12 views); M65239 (6 views); M67369 (16 views); M63710 (4 views); M65257 (4 views); M65233 (5 views); M65360 (4 views); M63584 (4 views); M66847 (16 views); M65333 (3 views); M65241 (5 views); M65351 (4 views); M63833 (8 views); M65353 (4 views); M63600 (4 views); M63758 (5 views); M65238 (5 views); M63659 (3 views); M63581 (5 views); M65339 (3 views); M65313 (3 views); M63867 (5 views); M65345 (5 views); M65331 (4 views); M65286 (9 views); M63414 (6 views); M66295 (10 views); M65302 (3 views); M63846 (8 views); M65341 (6 views); M68018 (14 views); M65314 (5 views); M65278 (4 views); M66843 (9 views); M65228 (5 views); M65264 (5 views); M63293 (8 views); M65311 (5 views); M66041 (12 views); M65708 (10 views); M66901 (9 views); M66290 (8 views); M65343 (5 views); M65757 (10 views); M65236 (5 views); M65247 (6 views); M63237 (6 views); M66888 (11 views); M66855 (11 views); M65710 (12 views); M67380 (10 views); M63788 (5 views); M63213 (5 views); M63741 (4 views); M67364 (12 views); M65297 (3 views); M63845 (7 views); M65290 (3 views); M63712 (6 views); M63217 (4 views); M65309 (3 views); M65688 (5 views); M65759 (7 views); M63209 (5 views); M65294 (4 views); M63856 (5 views); M65682 (11 views); M68019 (9 views); M63214 (7 views); M66829 (11 views); M65234 (7 views); M63692 (6 views); M65270 (4 views); M67366 (9 views); M65276 (3 views); M63590 (4 views); M63850 (5 views); M63246 (5 views); M63865 (8 views); M63702 (5 views); M66842 (8 views); M63768 (5 views); M65266 (6 views); M65359 (4 views); M63748 (6 views); M66291 (10 views); M63687 (7 views); M65267 (4 views); M63848 (5 views); M65329 (5 views); M66821 (12 views); M65347 (4 views); M65307 (4 views); M65298 (3 views); M63774 (7 views); M63729 (3 views); M67349 (14 views); M65293 (5 views); M63655 (7 views); M63855 (10 views); M65268 (4 views); M63843 (4 views); M65229 (4 views); M63732 (3 views); M65328 (3 views); M66047 (8 views); M66296 (12 views); M63737 (4 views); M65261 (5 views); M65356 (3 views); M65338 (4 views); M63765 (6 views); M63207 (3 views); M67375 (9 views); M65301 (4 views); M63598 (6 views); M65690 (10 views); M67377 (11 views); M65689 (17 views); M63836 (6 views); M89216 (13 views); M65322 (3 views); M65685 (8 views); M65284 (4 views); M65310 (4 views); M63716 (4 views); M65285 (5 views); M63752 (5 views); M66827 (8 views); M63754 (7 views); M65335 (4 views); M64057 (7 views); M63869 (7 views); M65273 (5 views); M63749 (5 views); M66899 (13 views); M63431 (5 views); M65243 (6 views); M67367 (8 views); M65252 (5 views); M65325 (7 views); M63718 (7 views); M63240 (6 views); M66846 (8 views); M66848 (10 views); M68011 (10 views); M66043 (13 views); M67381 (14 views); M63713 (4 views); M63772 (10 views); M63834 (5 views); M63433 (6 views); M65235 (5 views); M63840 (6 views); M65342 (3 views); M65349 (3 views); M65258 (4 views); M65253 (5 views); M65289 (5 views); M68017 (10 views); M65320 (5 views); M66822 (9 views); M63786 (4 views); M63241 (5 views); M63842 (4 views); M66854 (12 views); M63421 (4 views); M63853 (4 views); M63730 (3 views); M63723 (4 views); M63844 (4 views); M65334 (4 views); M67370 (10 views); M65681 (15 views); M65326 (3 views); M63362 (6 views); M67382 (11 views); M63733 (8 views); M63672 (6 views); M65362 (7 views); M63870 (6 views); M65246 (4 views); M65259 (4 views); M63841 (6 views); M63871 (7 views); M65250 (4 views); M65355 (4 views); M63759 (5 views); M63605 (6 views); M65245 (6 views); M63200 (8 views); M65321 (4 views); M64003 (6 views); M65262 (4 views); M63838 (4 views); M65265 (4 views); M65256 (3 views); M66283 (10 views); M65287 (6 views); M65354 (5 views); M66844 (12 views); M63839 (4 views); M65263 (4 views); M65237 (8 views); M65684 (14 views); M67360 (8 views); M63263 (3 views); M63803 (6 views); M63859 (5 views); M65242 (6 views); M65683 (11 views); M65300 (4 views); M63825 (5 views); M68010 (8 views); M65761 (10 views); M65336 (5 views); M68016 (12 views); M65244 (4 views); M65255 (4 views); M65337 (3 views); M65231 (4 views); M65271 (5 views); M66285 (8 views); M67342 (7 views); M65323 (2 views); M66287 (12 views); M65240 (3 views); M65350 (5 views); M65254 (4 views); M63674 (5 views); M65281 (2 views); M65319 (2 views); M67378 (11 views); M63703 (5 views); M63835 (4 views); M65303 (2 views); M66288 (7 views); M63587 (4 views); M66042 (10 views); M63959 (4 views); M63603 (4 views); M67986 (11 views); M67379 (11 views); M63194 (5 views); M65295 (2 views); M63823 (4 views); M65687 (9 views); M67352 (11 views); M66292 (9 views); M65291 (3 views); M63854 (12 views); M63215 (3 views); M65330 (4 views); M65299 (4 views); M67354 (17 views); M65318 (2 views); M63202 (4 views); M65272 (4 views); M63862 (4 views); M65348 (2 views); M65709 (11 views); M65296 (3 views); M66045 (9 views); M65269 (3 views); M66289 (9 views); M65711 (15 views); M63282 (7 views); M63773 (5 views); M65275 (6 views); M65274 (5 views); M66794 (7 views); M63822 (3 views); M65248 (4 views); M63861 (6 views); M65340 (5 views); M63832 (4 views); M63851 (5 views); M66898 (7 views); M65357 (2 views); M65316 (3 views); M63708 (4 views); M65305 (2 views); M65332 (2 views); M63831 (2 views); M65308 (2 views); M65288 (4 views); M63866 (5 views); M65260 (3 views); M66834 (10 views); M63747 (6 views); M63852 (3 views); M63406 (6 views); M63826 (4 views); M63864 (5 views); M63824 (3 views); M65317 (2 views); M66294 (17 views); M67376 (9 views); M63837 (4 views); M66286 (12 views); M66889 (7 views); M65361 (10 views); M63176 (7 views); M63147 (4 views); M63604 (7 views); M63739 (6 views); M63744 (4 views); M63273 (2 views); M63694 (6 views); M63283 (3 views); M63199 (3 views); M63727 (3 views); M63847 (7 views);
    Project overview4043
    Matrix views1865Matrix landing page (1610 views); supermatrix (255 views);
    Specimen list63844
    Taxon list4157
    Bibliography7771
    Documents list1168




    Project downloads

    type number of downloads Individual items downloaded (where applicable)
    Total downloads from project290
    Matrix downloads32supermatrix (32 downloads);
    Document downloads11Table S1 (1 download); Table S2 (2 downloads); Table S3 (4 downloads); Table S4 (2 downloads); Table S5 (1 download); Table S6 (1 download);
    Media downloads7M63827 (1 download); M63828 (1 download); M63829 (1 download); M63830 (1 download); M62597 (1 download); M62602 (1 download); M63200 (1 download);
    Project downloads240